Jesus Is the True Vine (John 15:1-8)

Introduction

The passage concerning ‘the vine and the branches’ in John 15:1-8 is a popular passage of Christian teaching and preaching. The current analysis will conduct an exegetical examination of the passage in order to understand its intended meaning and application. John 15:1-8 essentially functions to reveal that Jesus is the one true source of life and salvation, where union with Christ is the only means of newness of life for the further emanation of God’s glory. Analyzing the passage within its context, elucidating its teachings in exegesis, and summarizing those teachings with theological implications and practical applications will prove this conclusion.

Context

An exegetical analysis of John 15:1-8 must first locate the passage in its rightful context. This is accomplished by first analyzing the overall context of the Gospel of John, specifically noting its overall structure and purpose, and secondly by analyzing the particular context where the current passage is located.

The Gospel of John is divided into two books, the “Book of Signs” (1:19-12:50) and the “Book of glory” (13:1-21:25).[1] The first half of John’s Gospel provides a handful of specific ‘signs’ that primarily function to demonstrate the unique messianic person of Jesus Christ. The second half of John’s Gospel focuses on Jesus’ approach to his ‘hour of glory,’ his death, burial, and resurrection. However, John’s attempt to demonstrate the unique messianic person of Jesus Christ is not limited to the first half of his Gospel. The entire work is purposed ‘so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in his name’ (20:31). Therefore, the overall purpose of John’s Gospel is christologically evangelical, and thus every passage functions to reveal who Jesus is and what that means in regards to the readers’ response.

The particular context of John 15:1-8 is Jesus’ farewell discourse. The first part of the farewell discourse is found in 13:31-14:31; and the second part of the farewell discourse begins with 15:1-8 and continues on to 16:33. As Kostenberger noted, the farewell discourse has one primary purpose: “Jesus’ preparation of his followers for the immediate future – that is, the trauma and loss resulting from his crucifixion and burial – and the time after his ascension.”[2] For the current passage, one ought to contextually understand its teachings as a means for Jesus to prepare his disciples for the immediate future. Therefore, it is important to exegete the passage with an expectation of finding critical teachings that are necessary for the Christian life. Nonetheless, this specific contextual purpose serves the greater contextual purpose – i.e. these teachings that equip the Christian to live a Christian life are for the purpose of revealing important truths regarding the unique messianic person of Jesus.

Exegesis

John 15:1-8 teaches three identifications with the metaphorical imagery of the vine and the branches: (1) Jesus is the vine, (2) the Father is the vinedresser, and (3) Jesus’ disciples are the branches. These identifications are unpacked and elucidated in two main sections of the text, where 15:1-4 explains Jesus as the true vine and the Father as the vinedresser, and 15:5-8 explains that Jesus is the vine and therefore his disciples are the branches. In typical Johannine fashion, these identifications are mentioned in cycles and reiterated with further implications. The main identification of Jesus as the vine marks the beginning of each cycle (15:1a, 5a), where the first cycle emphasizes the Father’s role in Jesus as the vine, and the second cycle emphasizes the disciples’ role in Jesus as the vine. Therefore, the overall structure of the passage reveals the Jesus as the vine is the main teaching, and the other teachings provide a commentary and implications to this main teaching. The entire passage essentially functions to reveal that Jesus is the vine, and it subsequently functions to unpack what this means for one’s doctrine of God (the Father as Vinedresser in 15:1-4) and one’s Christian identity and ethic (Jesus’ disciples as the branches in 15:5-8). The fuller commentary and exposition of the metaphor in 15:1-8 is unpacked in 15:9-16, but the current exegesis will specifically focus on the metaphor described in 15:1-8.

Jesus is the True Vine and the Father is the Vinedresser (15:1-4)

The passage begins by affirming the primary Christological claim, ‘I am the true vine’ (15:1a), which is the last of Jesus’ seven ‘I am’ statements in John (cf. 6:35; 8:12; 10:7, 11; 11:25; 14:6).[3] As previously noted, John’s entire gospel is christologically purposed; therefore, understanding this broad context, the exegesis of the present passage ought to be understood in route to better understanding who Jesus was and is. The opening statement here makes it explicitly clear: Jesus is to be understood as the true vine. The imagery of the vine can be understood in a variety of ways, but given the later implications, it is best to understand the essential proposition – i.e. union with Christ is the source of salvation. A full exposition of this proposition is proved by the following exegesis, and is thus postponed until later analysis. The primary teaching here remains christological – that Jesus is the true vine (cf. the negation of ‘true’ in 15:5a). There is no other vine to which man can be united and saved. Given John’s extensive use of Old Testament themes, the ‘vine’ was often used as an image for the nation of Israel (Ps. 80:9-16; Isa. 5:1-7; 27:2ff; Jer. 2:21; 12:10ff; Ezek. 15:1-8; 17:1-21; 19:10-14; Hos. 10:1-2). Moreover, as Carson noted, “whenever historic Israel is referred to under this figure it is the vine’s failure to produce good fruit” (e.g. Isa. 5:1-7).[4] Such an expectation tied to the imagery of the vine paints a sharp contrast to Jesus’ claim – i.e. Jesus is the true vine that produces good fruit. Just as Jesus has surpassed and fulfilled the temple, Jewish rituals and feasts, and the prophet Moses, so also he is greater in regards to Israel’s fruitfulness. For John, Jesus’ greater work and person are the primary proofs of his messiahship, and the use of ‘vine’ functions to make a similar claim (cf. Psa. 80:7-17) in accordance with John’s overall purpose.

Unlike any of Jesus’ former ‘I am’ statements in the Gospel of John, this is the only one that provides an additional identification, ‘and my Father is the vinedresser’ (15:1b). Looking back to Psalm 80 and Isaiah 5, the Father’s role as the vinedresser is expected. However, the implication for John here further unpacks the Trinitarian teachings that have been presented throughout his gospel.[5] Although Jesus is God, he also with God, subordinate to the Father (cf. 5:19). The further elucidation of the Father’s role as vinedresser is unpacked in 15:2.

As Pentecost commented, “The responsibility of a gardener [vinedresser] was to tend vines so that the vines could produce fruit.”[6] The Father fulfills this role, and as noted here, it is for the purpose of the vine’s fruitfulness. God the Father’s role as the vinedresser is explained by two main activities: (1) the Father takes away unfruitful branches (15:2a), and (2) the Father prunes fruitful branches (15:2b). Looking forward in the passage, one understands the branches to be Jesus’ disciples. Therefore, the Father takes away those disciples who do not produce fruit, and he prunes those disciples who do produce fruit. Fruitfulness is a broad image for the disciple’s obedience and love (cf. 15:10) – i.e. the Father ‘takes away’ disobedient disciples and ‘prunes’ obedient disciples.[7] Further explanation of the metaphorical imagery of the Father’s ‘taking away’ is provided in 15:6; and the Father’s ‘pruning’ is further explained in 15:7. Postponing those references until later in the exegesis, one can still gain a better understanding of the Father’s ‘pruning’ by observing the purpose clause attached to it, ‘that it may bear more fruit’ (15:2c). The Father ‘prunes’ obedient disciples of Jesus in order that they may be more obedient and loving. Therefore, the pruning process is a productive one, one that is ultimately purposed in bringing the Father more glory (15:8) and the disciple more joy (15:11). As Carson noted, “Doubtless the Father’s purpose is loving…but the procedure may be painful” (cf. Heb. 12:4-11).[8]

In light of the noted function of the Father’s role as vinedresser, Jesus provides a preemptive parenthetical consolation for his disciples. Jesus’ disciples are already clean by Jesus’ word (15:3). Carson explained, “The cleansing power of the word Jesus has spoken to his disciples is equivalent to the life of the vine pulsating through the branches.”[9] It is the disciples’ relation to Jesus as the source of life and salvation that cleanses them – the emphasis again being that it is Jesus who is the true vine, the source of cleansing.

However, Jesus’ consolation of the disciples’ cleanliness is not without instruction. The noted indicative functions to provide a confidence and propulsion for the imperative, ‘abide in me’ (15:4). The disciples are called to abide in Christ because he is the source of life. Just as a branch is incapable of producing fruit apart from the vine, so a disciple is incapable of obeying apart from their abiding in Jesus. This primary teaching is communicated whether the syntax is conditional, a comparison, or a mutual imperative – i.e. “continuous dependence on the vine, constant reliance on him, persistent spiritual imbibing of his life – this is the sine qua non of spiritual fruitfulness.”[10]

Jesus is the Vine and His Disciples Are the Branches (15:5-8)

The next cycle begins by reiterating the primary claim that began the first cycle, ‘Jesus is the vine (15:5a). Again, this is main teaching of the overall passage, and it functions to demonstrate that Jesus is the promised messiah. However, in the reiteration the similarity provides the foundation to expose the distinct emphases – i.e. where the previous cycle focused on the implication of God’s role in Jesus as the vine, this cycle focuses on the implication of the disciples’ role in Jesus as the vine (though the latter is not completely foreign in the first cycle). So Jesus repeats the christological claim, ‘I am the vine,’ and further adds that his disciples are the branches (15:5b). The clarification provides greater explicit reference to the metaphorical imagery, whereas it was previously implied; and it is this reference to the disciples as the branches and its implications that is further explained in the proceeding verses.

Now with the explicit reference to the disciples as the branches connected to the vine, Jesus reiterates the essential teaching from 15:4 – he is the source of fruitfulness for the disciples (15:5c). Whoever abides in Christ will bear much fruit; and this is because apart from the vine, the branches can do nothing. The distinction here from 15:4 is the slight clarification that it is ‘whoever’ that can abide in Christ and produce fruit. Jesus as the life-giving source of salvation is not limited to current disciples, the Jewish people, or any peoples with a preceding qualification. The same union to Christ that the disciples have been given can be accessed by whoever has faith in Jesus, who believes in him and abides in him.

Likewise, whoever does not abide in Jesus – the one true vine and source of salvation – suffers the rightful consequences (cf. Isa. 5:5-6; Ezek. 15:1-8). Non-abiding branches are thrown away and destroyed (15:6). Such a result poses a significant question regarding the perseverance of the saints. Can those who were once ‘in Jesus’ be cut off and destroyed? However, such a logical inference understands the metaphorical imagery of the passage too literally. For one, John has already emphasized the perseverance of the saints throughout his gospel (cf. 6:37-40; 10:28). Secondly, as Carson noted, “the transparent purpose of the verse is to insist that there are no true Christians without some measure of fruit.”[11] The passage is not seeking to unfold the intricacies of justification and sanctification; rather Jesus is making the simple claim that true Christians, true disciples of Christ, produce fruit. Here, that simple claim is stated in the negative – i.e. those who are not united to Jesus Christ therefore do not produce fruit. As a result of their unfruitfulness, which is a result of their non-abiding in Christ, the righteous Father takes them away unto just judgment and destruction. The most profane offense of all humanity is the rejection of Jesus Christ, and such profanity committed against the infinitely righteous and holy God is completely deserving of destruction.

Jesus continues by further clarifying the fruitfulness of the abiding branches – i.e. they have their requests answered (15:7). It was previously mentioned that the ‘fruit’ of the branches generally referred to the disciples’ obedience. However, in light of this verse, obedience appears to be too limited of a reference. ‘Fruitfulness’ certainly implies obedience, but it is not the sum of the disciples’ fruitfulness. 15:4-5 showed that those who abide in Christ produce fruit. Here in 15:7, Jesus claims that those who abide in him will have their prayers answered. Carson concluded,

This suggests that the ‘fruit’ in the vine imagery represents everything that is the product of effective prayer in Jesus’ name, including obedience to Jesus’ commands (v. 10), experience of Jesus’ joy (v. 11 – as earlier his peace, 14:27), love for one another (v. 12), and witness to the world (vv. 16, 27).[12]

The fruitfulness of abiding branches certainly includes the expression of obedience, but their obedience occurs in the context of several other expressions. The fruits noted by Carson provided a glimpse into those fruits attested by the Johannine context, but a canonical analysis can further include the fruits of the Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control (Gal. 5:22-23). Perhaps in one phrase, the fruitfulness of the abiding disciple can be summarized as ‘newness of life’ (Rom. 6:4).

It is this ‘newness of life,’ the fruitfulness of the abiding disciple that ultimately functions to glorify the Father (15:8). As the Westminster Catechism states, the chief end of man is to “glorify God (1 Cor. 10:31) and enjoy him forever (Psa. 73:25-26).”[13] In light of this chief end of man’s creation and design, it is only natural that all of God’s redemptive work would ultimately labor to bring about the further emanation of his glory. The passage itself provides several means and ends – e.g. Jesus’ disciples prove to be disciples by their fruitfulness, fruitfulness is only accomplished by one’s abiding in Jesus, fruitfulness is only accomplished in Jesus because Jesus is the true vine, Jesus is the true vine because he is the messiah, etc. and so on – but it is this statement that provides the ultimate purpose for all that has been previously mentioned and all that will be mentioned. The further glorification of God is the ultimate end and the ultimate purpose for all his work. This includes the work of redemption for all creation, the work of salvation in the disciples of Jesus, the work of Jesus to obtain that salvation, etc. By supplying his disciples with the ultimate purpose for all of his teaching and instruction, Jesus places eternity into their eyes, and thus provides them with the foundational motivation for their proper application. This ultimate purpose of fruitfulness is also noted with an additional purpose, where one’s fruitfulness proves that he or she is a disciple of Jesus Christ. It is only logical that if it is only those who are united with the true vine that bear fruit, then those that bear fruit ‘prove’ that they are Jesus’ disciples. The proof of one’s identity is found in one’s activity. One could say that this additional purpose provides a hinted implication of personal benefit. The hinted implication is made further explicit in 15:11, ‘these things I have spoken to you, that my joy may be in you, and that your joy may be full.’ The connection between these two stated purposes – God’s glorification and his disciples’ joy – was best worded by John Piper, “God is most glorified in us when we are most satisfied in him.”[14] The disciple’s fruitfulness is a means to an end, and that is the ultimate end of God’s glorification, which is an eternal fountain of joy for the fruitful disciple.

Theological Implications and Application

Several theological teachings can be identified in this passage. A summary of those teachings is as follows: (1) Jesus is the vine, the promised messiah, the one true source of life and salvation. (2) The Father is the vinedresser who functions to maximize the fruitfulness of Jesus’ disciples. (3) Amid a Trinitarian background, Jesus is subordinate to the Father. (4) Whoever desires to follow Jesus must be united to him by faith and abide in him. (5) Abiding disciples of Jesus Christ will live in the newness of life and be ‘pruned’ to produce more fruit. (6) Those who reject Jesus do not abide in Him and suffer judgment unto destruction. (7) The ultimate purpose for the disciples abiding in Christ and bearing fruit is for the further emanation of God’s glory. All of these teaching culminate to serve John’s great christological purpose – i.e. they are written ‘so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in his name.’ (20:31).

In light of these theological teachings, some practical applications can be observed. The unbeliever should come to believe in Jesus as the Christ, the culminating fulfillment of God’s promises and salvation. Upon understanding Jesus to be the true vine, the one true source of life and salvation, one should seek to be united to him. This union is not some unattainable mysticism, though it is mystical; but it practically calls for faith, a position of relational dependence and trust in who Jesus is and what he has accomplished. The Christian ought to continue to pursue further fruitfulness through their union with Christ. In a correct understanding of who Jesus is, all attempts to be fruitful and live in the newness of life must be centered on the desire to draw from Jesus as the true source. Growing in one’s walk with God requires continual and relational dependence on the Lord Jesus Christ. There is no warrant to stall in the Christian life, and any lack of fruitfulness ought to stir the Christian to return to the source of fruitfulness. The desire for fruitfulness most genuinely arises from one’s understanding of the ultimate purpose of God’s redemption – i.e. his glorification. The one who has a genuine affection and motivation for the further emanation of God’s glory will naturally seek to be fruitful for his name’s sake. Only such a motivation will sustain a Christian through God’s loving disciplinary process of pruning; and it is by God’s grace that this motivation and application will be accompanied by fullness of joy in Christ.

Conclusion

John 15:1-8 essentially teaches the messiahship of Jesus Christ, revealing him to be the true source of newness of life. All people are called to be united with Jesus in order to live in this newness of life and joyfully spread God’s glory. Eternal life is a matter of being in a relationship with Jesus Christ; and in the actualization of one’s relationship with Jesus, God will be glorified by their consequential newness of life.

[1] Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel According to John: Introduction, Translation and Notes, 2nd ed., AYB (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1966), 1.cxxxviii-cxxxix.

[2] Andreas J. Kostenberger, Encountering John, 2nd ed. (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2013), 131.

[3] See the summary table in Andreas J. Köstenberger, L Scott Kellum, and Charles L. Quarles, The Cradle, the Cross, and the Crown: An Introduction to the New Testament (Nashville, TN: B & H Academic, 2009), 306.

[4] D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John, PNTC (Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans Pub. Co., 1990), 513.

[5] See Andreas Kostenberger and Scott R. Swain, Father, Son and Spirit: The Trinity and John’s Gospel, New Studies in Biblical Theology, vol. 24, ed. D. A. Carson (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2008).

[6] Dwight J. Pentecost, The Words and Works of Jesus Christ (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1981), 441.

[7] Robert H. Gundry commented, “The fruitbearing of branches represents obedience to Jesus’ commands, most especially the one that believers should love one another,” in A Survey of the New Testament, 4th ed. (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2003), 284.

[8] Carson, The Gospel According to John, 514.

[9] Ibid., 515.

[10] Ibid., 516. Also see Carson’s comments on the syntactical options, 516.

[11] Ibid.,, 515.

[12] Ibid., 517.

[13] G. I. Williamson, The Westminster Shorter Catechism: For Study Classes, 2nd ed. (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R Publishing, 2003), 1.

[14] John Piper, God’s Passion for His Glory: Living the Vision of Jonathan Edwards (Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 1998), 47.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s